Updated Tier List of Adventures I have run

26 Jan, 2026

Here is a quick update to my tier list of adventures I have run! It has been more than a year since I published the original list, the following adventures I have played since then:

New to the List

• Stonehell
• Rotblack Sludge
• Raiders of the Hidden Temple
• Wavestone Monolith
• Sablewood Messengers
• The Ogre
• Rotblack Sludge
• Barrow of the Bone Blaggards
• Shadowdark Adventure Anthology: Halls of the Dwarf Lord

And here is how they slot into the tier list:

S Tier

• Waking of Willowby Hall (SD)
• Winter’s Daughter (SD)
• The Lightless Beacon (CoC)
• Sailors of the Starless Sea (DCC)
• I6: Castle Ravenloft (SD)

A Tier

• Portal under the Stars (DCC)
• Sablewood Messengers (Daggerheart)
• Rotblack Sludge (Mörk Borg)
• Cursed Scroll #1: Hideous Halls of Mugdublub (SD)
• Demon Driven to the Maw (Cairn)
• Black Wyrm of Brandonsford (OSE)
• Electric Bastionland: Generators (EB)
• A Most Potent Brew (5e)
• Prepared 2: Night at the Odeum (5e)

B Tier

• Barrow of the Elf King (Cairn)
• Wyvern Songs: Peacock Point (S&W)
• Shadowdark Adventure Anthology: Halls of the Dwarflord (SD)
• The Ogre (Mythic Bastionland)
• Stonehell (SD)
• Wavestone Monolith (SD)
• Barrow of the Bone Blaggards (5e)
• Dragon of Icespire Peak (5e)

C Tier

• Raiders of the Hidden Temple (SD)
• Candlekeep Mysteries: Wisteria Vale (5e)
• Edge of Darkness (CoC)
• The Necropolis (CoC)
• Dungeon of the Mad Mage (5e)
• Candlekeep Mysteries: Scrivener’s Tale (5e)
• Glory of the Giants: Giants of the Star Forge (5e)

D Tier

• Scarlet Citadel (5e)

#adventure #list #review